11 replies to this topic

[Slightly Wonky Robob]

Sig of the Week #89 Voting

Theme: The Stone Age
Voting Deadline: Sunday, 17th May 2009. Midnight GMT
Original Topic: SotW #89

Entries

Motoshi


Lord Atlantis


Abourror


WNxMastrefubu


Enceladus


The Dr Source

Edited by Bob, 16 May 2009 - 22:38.

[BeefJeRKy]

Lord Atlantis
Enceladus
Abourror

Also, more renders for later SOTWs if you want to make it a contest about sigmaking skills. Whereas for creativity stick to FFAs I guess.

[Dauth]

LA
Abourror
Motoshi

More themed comps, this provided some excellent sigs

[Ion Cannon!]

LA
Abourror
TheDr

Can't really tell what motoshi's is as its to dark.
Abourror would have taken first place for me but the sky cuts off, it would have looked better if the sky had filled the pop-up area.

If you want to have a large response to SOTW I think FFA is the way to go. There were many different types of sigs last week and many where high quality.

[CJ]

Abourror
Lord Atlantis
The Dr

I agree with Dauth, Themed SotW FTW =)
As long as the themes are interesting enough

Edited by Carl, 16 May 2009 - 22:53.

[Dr. Knickers]

Enceladus
Abourror
Atlantis
FFA

Edited by Eto, 16 May 2009 - 23:09.

[Pav:3d]

Arbourrour
Enceladus
Lord Atlantis

More renders, or actually accept suggested themes

[Silence]

Abourrour
Enceladus
Lord Atlantis

Specific Themes

As long as the themes are very interesting. Or maybe a, "Make a Sig out of this Render" Theme.
And how about once a month FFA. That I guess should equalize the Themes

[Pav:3d]

"More Renders" IS a "Make a Sig out of this Render" Theme Silence

[Enceladus]

Abourror
The Dr
Lord Atlantis.

More render themes but keep a constant flow of FFa's as well.

[ΓΛPTΘΓ]

Abourror
Lord Atlantis
Enceladus

FFA

[Slightly Wonky Robob]

Motoshi		   0 +  2 + 2 =  4
Lord Atlantis	21 +  8 + 5 = 34
Abourror		 24 + 14 + 3 = 41
WNxMastrefubu	 0 +  0 + 4 =  4
Enceladus		 9 +  6 + 1 = 16
The Dr			3 +  8 + 4 = 15

I was going to add a new rule about how the voting system works, but I forgot . Thankfully it wouldn't have effected anything this week anyway. Last week we had a draw for third place, and I think there has been at least one more incident in the past like this. On those occasions I simply gave both people a medal. For future competitions I will award the medal to the person who has the most first place votes, if both have the same I will move to second place, then on to third, if both people have the same for that as well then and only then I will award the 2 people with the same medal.

Following on from the fourth poll, the general consesus seems to be that people want more FFA, however there are still some people that want more themes and renders. So I have decided to change to doing 2 weeks of FFA then a week of a theme or render (depending on what ideas are floating about). This is just a rough guide so don't hold me to that pattern. To those that wanted more renders, and anyone else that is willing to help, I would appreciate it if you can add any renders that you think might work to the SotW Suggestions thread. Renders should be roughly twice the size of the average sig (or bigger) and preferably already cut out.

Edited by Bob, 18 May 2009 - 16:04.