2198 replies to this topic

[BeefJeRKy]

9.5/10 Excellent cut of the render. The effects to the left work great as well. If only the render was less misty.

[ΓΛPTΘΓ]

6/10

Too blurry on the main render, too boxy for my liking and font + background doesn't blend in that well.

[Destiny]

9/10 Shana.

The box needs a bit more detailing.

[Silence]

9/10 - nothing more to say

[Destiny]

8/10 Oh...epic Shock Orchid...I wonder if the PACs are nearby.

[Comr4de]

Changed it a bit, though I preferred the stylized way you had the text. 8/10

[TheDR]

10/10

I just really like it, its awesome.

[CJ]

9/10
I like the use of transparency used to get the render out of the sig, but the font used for The DR is.. meh...

[Lord Atlantis]

10/10

[ΓΛPTΘΓ]

8/10 the repeated trooper look a bit out of place. =/

Maybe a different render at the back?

Still very nice though.

[CJ]

9/10 also, I find that the background is a little boring where there is your nick

[WNxMastrefubu]

10/10

[CJ]

Hey I keep getting 10/10 for my sig, didn't know it was so good Oo
*bets 5$ that scope is gonna put a lower rating on it =p*

8/10 for Fubu because there is a black shadow at the left (near the buildings and behind the bird) which makes the siggy look weird
Rain effect is well done though

Edited by Carl, 10 May 2009 - 17:39.

[BeefJeRKy]

9.5/10 Because I prefer the new Prince of Persia

[CJ]

You gonna kill me but I must stay objective, part of my old job on art communities =p
6.5/10

*hides*

Well the render is too blurry, and does not fit with the BG
But as The Dr said, it's good for a first try
Tip : Eat more tutorials, they're offered with cookies =D

PS : The new prince of persia sucks (because I can't afford it )

Edited by Carl, 10 May 2009 - 18:22.

[TheDR]

@Scope:
Better than most first tries

The text should not be the focus of the sig, which in yours it is as the main render is too blurred and the main Bg colour is not nice to look at.
But the good points are the placement of the render, the text placement is good, the way it bends round is done very well.

@Carl:
Feels a tad empty to the left but otherwise its good.

[CJ]

@The Dr : Am I dreaming or did you change the brightness ?
-0.1 Because of the outlines on the render =p
+1 for changing the font

Result : 0/10

[Pandut]

9.9/10

It's crazy awesome

[Silence]

9/10 - The army are sehxe in gray..uhm should have positioned the name in a much better place (which I cant think of)

[Destiny]

8/10 Gunslinger Girls The image is pretty sharp though.

[Comr4de]

Trippy but there's something that I don't like about it 7/10

[Pandut]

9.9/10 Made from pure win

[TheDR]

Il rate Comr4de's for obvious reasons

10/10, i really like it

[ΓΛPTΘΓ]

8/10 A different font might works better.

[Ion Cannon!]

I don't think all the yellow stuff surrounding the render works well but otherwise pretty nice. 7/10.