344 replies to this topic

[Futschki]

Thanks For Being Honest

[Futschki]

what do u guys say about this one :

[Nexolate]

Three words:

-Far
-Too
-Big

[Slightly Wonky Robob]

^agreed

[Sic]

I fully agree.

[Futschki]

:( I just asked about what is inside it

[Slightly Wonky Robob]

no you said, 'what do you say about this one'

and we said it was too big

but if you want a comment on the content and lookd of the sig, TBH its not overly impressive all it is is several renders slapped on "render>clouds"

i mean no offense, but you really need to do more experimenting

Edited by Bob, 23 December 2006 - 18:04.

[Futschki]

New One :

What do u say ?

[Nexolate]

Lack of Render, Single Stroke Border, Contrasting Font Colour.

5/10

The background's ok I suppose, if you made it.

[Futschki]

Yea I made it
this one :

better ?

Edited by abourror, 02 January 2007 - 19:12.

[Nexolate]

Much, 7/10.

[Futschki]

Two Other :


Ratings ?

[E.V.E.]

I like the Scnd one more. The 1st one looks - kind of wierd. 6/10

The scnd one is, let´s say 8/10. I personally just would do it a bit darker.
But I dont know, I haven´t got any experience in that anyway so ...

-E.V.E.

Edited by E.V.E., 03 January 2007 - 15:43.

[Nexolate]

What's with the rainbow Sigs? The most effective sigs have a general flow with colour. Yours is all over the place.

Both 6/10.

Edited by No-Skillz, 03 January 2007 - 15:48.

[Sic]

Nothing blends. It's good, but if it was blended it'd be better. Border and Background don't even get near the render.

Edited by General Sic, 03 January 2007 - 20:47.

[Nexolate]

General Sic, on 3 Jan 2007, 15:48, said:

Border, and render don't even get near the render.

Lol, hurray for typos.

[Futschki]

I dont understand you guys

[Sic]

Fixed. Had a headache when saying that.

[zill]

he's right i mean sic

[Slightly Wonky Robob]

yeah, you really need to get the flow of sigs

ive only seen a couple of good sigs from you, i rate these:

1) 4.5/10
2) 5.5/10

[Futschki]

can u explain what is so baad about this sig ?

[Slightly Wonky Robob]

- Text is hard to read, because of font type and font colour
- Colours dont match/mirror render
- Renders just put on top of background
- Border way too big for the type of border
- There is no overall flow to the sig

i dont mean to be harsh, im just trying to be more honest with people, so they (you) can improve

[Nexolate]

Without getting better at Photoshop, the easiest thing to do would be to make the sig flow better. As in have a general colour and use different tones instead of vastly different colours.

[Slightly Wonky Robob]

One thing you could do, is add a hue/saturation layer, tick colorize and then pick a colour, that way you have a colour scheme running throuhout

[Sic]

I prefer color balance more. You can tweak it more, and you can specify the color of Shadows/Highlights/Midtones.

Edited by General Sic, 04 January 2007 - 17:03.