Best Metal/Rockband pt 2
Reaper94
19 May 2008
request closure of old topic: old and crap, new one up
also seing as metallica prettymuch butchered the old thread it neads some compitition, most of the new ones are ones people complained wernt up there
better?
Edited by Gaara, 20 May 2008 - 21:23.
also seing as metallica prettymuch butchered the old thread it neads some compitition, most of the new ones are ones people complained wernt up there
Ion Cannon!, on 4 Mar 2008, 23:05, said:
Someone should make a proper poll with miles more bands. This one is very limited.
better?
Edited by Gaara, 20 May 2008 - 21:23.
Mbob61
19 May 2008
GnR almost got my vote but its gotta be Led Zeppelin for me
They are amazing
Mike
They are amazing
Mike
Libains
19 May 2008
Guns and Roses (just) for me - narrowly edging out Led Zep. Lot of good bands up there - but also some that aren't so great...
Cryptkeeper
20 May 2008
disturbed is not there or ac dc :o
Edited by Cryptkeeper, 20 May 2008 - 03:18.
Edited by Cryptkeeper, 20 May 2008 - 03:18.
TehKiller
20 May 2008
AC/DC FTW!!!!
though Sabbath was close for the vote
Edited by TehKiller, 20 May 2008 - 09:54.
though Sabbath was close for the vote
Edited by TehKiller, 20 May 2008 - 09:54.
The Wandering Jew
20 May 2008
All are good, so I did not vote.
Too bad Earth Crisis, Pantera, Poison the Well are not on the list, though.
Too bad Earth Crisis, Pantera, Poison the Well are not on the list, though.
Shirou
20 May 2008
Maiden fo' sho'
Only complaints on the poll are to replace Dragonforce with Stratovarius, the fathers of the genre in its current form.
...and I cried seeing slipknot up there..
Edited by Aftershock, 20 May 2008 - 12:11.
Only complaints on the poll are to replace Dragonforce with Stratovarius, the fathers of the genre in its current form.
...and I cried seeing slipknot up there..
Edited by Aftershock, 20 May 2008 - 12:11.
Pav:3d
20 May 2008
Zeppelin, they did it first!
And again no motorhead hinata? Daym...
agreed with aftershock
slipknot is an ugly smear on that list
And again no motorhead hinata? Daym...
agreed with aftershock
slipknot is an ugly smear on that list
Reaper94
20 May 2008
van halen removed motorhead added
trying to get it close as close as the first i did (the poll didnbt come up)
trying to get it close as close as the first i did (the poll didnbt come up)
E.V.E.
20 May 2008
Rolling Stones, Megadeth, Fear Factory and Clutch.
Clutch is awesome for biking around.
- E.V.E.
Edited by E.V.E., 20 May 2008 - 14:14.
Clutch is awesome for biking around.
- E.V.E.
Edited by E.V.E., 20 May 2008 - 14:14.
Shirou
20 May 2008
Poll question is not good. Make it 'best rock/metal band, not Favorite'. Fav is totally too subjective. For Best I can nominate others than my favorite music.
Within such a discussion you shouldnt only let your own opinion be the guide to your 'band that neeeed to be added omg!!' decision. Take into account other things like.
General popularity
The time they are around (no seriously, Korn? drowning pool? When they quit everybody will forget them within a year)
The legacy they will leave if they quit, and if it will stand long
Their musical achievements! Bands copying off other bands can be very popular but hell no should they be the best if there was an earlier band who is at least just as popular, who invented the entire music (figure my Stratovarius nomination). A good example of a band who wouldnt get the title from me because of this, is megadeth, while ofcourse it is good enough for nomination.
Fear Factory would be in their because of their influence in the current american metal scene, which is immense.
Within such a discussion you shouldnt only let your own opinion be the guide to your 'band that neeeed to be added omg!!' decision. Take into account other things like.
General popularity
The time they are around (no seriously, Korn? drowning pool? When they quit everybody will forget them within a year)
The legacy they will leave if they quit, and if it will stand long
Their musical achievements! Bands copying off other bands can be very popular but hell no should they be the best if there was an earlier band who is at least just as popular, who invented the entire music (figure my Stratovarius nomination). A good example of a band who wouldnt get the title from me because of this, is megadeth, while ofcourse it is good enough for nomination.
Fear Factory would be in their because of their influence in the current american metal scene, which is immense.
Reaper94
20 May 2008
Aftershock, on 20 May 2008, 21:50, said:
Poll question is not good. Make it 'best rock/metal band, not Favorite'. Fav is totally too subjective. For Best I can nominate others than my favorite music.
Within such a discussion you shouldnt only let your own opinion be the guide to your 'band that neeeed to be added omg!!' decision. Take into account other things like.
Within such a discussion you shouldnt only let your own opinion be the guide to your 'band that neeeed to be added omg!!' decision. Take into account other things like.
done
and i can only add bands ive heard off...
and i finally cast myvote, after hearing more of metallica (eye of the beholder, ...And Justice For All) they win my vote
with maiden as a very close 2nd
Ion Cannon!
21 May 2008
Gaara, on 19 May 2008, 20:21, said:
request closure of old topic: old and crap, new one up
also seing as metallica prettymuch butchered the old thread it neads some compitition, most of the new ones are ones people complained wernt up there
better?
also seing as metallica prettymuch butchered the old thread it neads some compitition, most of the new ones are ones people complained wernt up there
Ion Cannon!, on 4 Mar 2008, 23:05, said:
Someone should make a proper poll with miles more bands. This one is very limited.
better?
I don't think you got my point. There are so many metal / rock bands its nearly impossible to account for them all. I can name another 10 right now that are very good and not on that list.
In Flames, Children of Bodom, Disturbed, Scar Symmetry, Dark Tranquility, All That Remains, Killswitch Engage, Machinehead - Do I really need to go on?
There is simply to much diversity and such a wide range of bands that you cannot have a comprehensive poll.
Cryptkeeper
21 May 2008
best ? isn't that just a subjective as favorite :O but yah theres too many bands really
