2198 replies to this topic

[Vaughan]

8/10

Nice color scheme, might need some more shoppy goodness. It relies on the render too much. :o

~V.

[TheDR]

The depth and effects are cool, must of taken a lot of tweaking. Its a bit let down because the main image looks a bit pixelated around the edges, but that might just be because of where its from.

8.8/10

[Dr.Schwarzk0pf]

10/10 i love it

[Vaughan]

7/10

Ahhh, I love Godzilla!

~V.

[Nem]

Great style, Poor quality. 6/10

[Libains]

*Brings back to life*
Good quality, the cut around the edges doesn't look messy enough to be random damage, but doesn't look neat enough to show it's supposed to be there. 8/10

[Pav:3d]

Nice, i love the bg, where is it from? (or the brushes u made it with or w/e)

[E-713 Aegis]

Absolutely awesome! I love how the green contrasts with the rest of it. 9/10

[Libains]

A simple sig, little more than a tweaked screenie tbh. Simple is often effective though - 6/10

[E-713 Aegis]

lol, mine isn't even tweaked, I just haven't had anyone work on it yet.

As for yours, I'd say 7/10, I like the muted colors and such.

[Libains]

The muted colours are there for a reason - there's something about that image that would surprise you

[TheDR]

I like it, but its a little too big for my preferences. Also, the image in your sig is amazingly overused, but thats not a problem
Also, maybe the render in your avatar could do with a bit of saturation, so it matches the sig.

So i like the overall design, text, placement ect. but its feels like its overly large when it doesn't need to be. 7.5/10

[Dr.Schwarzk0pf]

97/100

[Admiral Wesley]

8/10

[Libains]

Not bad, but the image doesn't quite lend itself to that effect, you've lost too much of his head into the BG.

And before anyone says anything: I KNOW IT'S BIG!

[Brad]

ITS HUGE
Still though, I think the style and colour suit the render nicely, and the font is nothing but the best for that render and concept.
Its also a little simple, it only being a rectangle coloured with a gradient with a popout.
Still, very nice. I'd say... 9/10

[ΓΛPTΘΓ]

text/10

[Libains]

Blue/10

I'd give it 7/10 - the hair is too sharply cut off, and the text is too small for me.

[CJ]

8.88/10
I won't talk about the good sides as that would include almost everything so the bad points are :
- Hair rendering is choppy
- Too big D:
- Text is not well placed, it's too close to the top

[BeefJeRKy]

Build sig nao! Right now its a 3/10 for a good quote but no sig image

[Libains]

8/10

The cut for the bloke was rather epic, but the sig's borders aren't quite right and over/underlap, sadly.

Variation of old sig, hair is sorted, text is lowered now, btw

[TheDR]

Wait, did you just rate your own sig?

Cut is really nice and overall sig, text, colour ect. are done well.
The only bit i dislike is that the render seems to be slightly faded near the bottom.

7/10, its nice simple sig.

[Nem]

Zomg awesome 8/10

[Libains]

Nem, on 12 Oct 2009, 0:22, said:

Zomg awesome 8/10

Nice and simple, my kind of sig. Maybe a little too much black on the right, and lack of a name is a little meh, but still ace. 8.5/10

[Warbz]

9/10 background is a tad bland. Awesome cut though.

Edited by W!, 11 October 2009 - 23:27.